Is Your Church Website Design Outdated? Discover 7 Signs That Say 'Yes

Mar 1, 2023

Alright, picture this: It's Sunday morning, and you've just finished brewing your favorite coffee. You sit down at your computer, ready to check out the website of a local church someone recently recommended. You're curious, excited, and a bit nervous. But when the site finally loads, it's like a digital time machine has transported you back to the late 1990s. You squint at your screen, trying to navigate through tiny text and grainy images. Your excitement deflates like a day-old birthday balloon.

Sound familiar? You're not alone. As a pastor or church leader, you want your church to feel welcoming to everyone, both in-person and online. But if your website is giving off "dial-up internet" vibes, it might be time for an update. And that's where we come in. We're a Church Digital Marketing Agency, and we specialize in creating beautiful, user-friendly church websites that reflect the vibrancy and spirit of your congregation.

The Role of Websites in Church Outreach

Think of your website as your church's digital front door. It's often the first impression people get of your church, and we all know how much first impressions count.

I remember when I first moved to a new city and was looking for a church to attend. I turned to Google, as one does these days, and found a church nearby. But when I clicked on their website, I was met with a confusing layout, outdated information, and an unfortunate color scheme that reminded me of my grandmother's kitchen in the 70s. Even though their mission resonated with me, I couldn't get past the chaotic website, and I ended up looking elsewhere. It was a wake-up call about the power a website has to attract or deter potential members.

But enough about the past, let's dive into the present and future! Here are seven signs that your church website might be in need of a little TLC.

Sign #1: Your Website Isn't Mobile-Friendly

Picture this: Someone hears about your church while they're out and about. They whip out their smartphone to look you up, but your website looks like a jigsaw puzzle with all the pieces in the wrong place. They can't read the tiny text, the images are off the screen, and they have to scroll sideways just to find your service times. It's a frustrating experience, and they give up, moving on to the next church on their list.

That's the reality for many people when they visit a site that isn't mobile-friendly. As of 2021, more than half of all web traffic comes from mobile devices. That's a lot of people using their phones and tablets to explore the web, and you want to make sure your church's website is ready for them.

Think about it this way: Your website should be like a favorite old hymn—it works no matter where it's played, be it a grand cathedral or a simple home gathering. Similarly, your website should shine no matter what device it's viewed on.

Sign #2: It's Difficult to Find Information

Have you ever gone to a website looking for specific information, only to get lost in a labyrinth of confusing menus and pages? It's like trying to find the holy grail, but without the fun of a quest and the promise of eternal youth.

Your church's website should make it easy for visitors to find what they're looking for, whether that's service times, your location, contact information, or the latest sermons. Imagine your website like your church's bulletin—it's got all the important info right there at a glance, not hidden away.

Here's a little story for you: I once visited a church website where the pastor's bio was hidden under the "Events" section. Events! Now, while I'm sure the pastor is a lively character, I'm not sure that's quite the right place for that information. That's an extreme example, but it just goes to show how vital clear navigation is. Your website visitors will thank you for it!

Sign #3: Outdated Aesthetics

Imagine walking into a church for the first time, and it looks like it hasn't seen a fresh coat of paint since the '80s. The carpet is an indeterminate color, the wallpaper is peeling, and there's a suspicious stain on one of the pews that you're pretty sure is older than you are. You might start wondering, "Is this place still active? Do people still come here?"

Well, your website is no different. If it looks like it was built during the era of dial-up internet, people might question how active or relevant your church is. Today's websites are all about clean lines, easy-to-read fonts, and high-quality images. It's not about being flashy—it's about creating a welcoming and modern space where people can feel at home.

Once upon a time, I worked with a church that had a website that can only be described as "retro"—and not in a good way. The background was a repeating tile of a dove, there were sparkly GIFs everywhere, and Comic Sans was the font of choice. It was like a time capsule from the early days of the internet. When we updated it to a clean, modern design, they were amazed at the increase in online engagement. The lesson? Never underestimate the power of a design refresh!

Sign #4: Slow Load Times

Have you ever clicked on a website, only to find that it takes forever to load? It's like waiting for a pot of coffee to brew on a Monday morning—painfully slow and a test of your patience.

If your website is taking more than a few seconds to load, you might be losing visitors. Studies show that people are likely to abandon a site if it takes longer than three seconds to load. Three seconds! In the time it takes to say, "Hallelujah," your potential visitors might have moved on.

I once had a friend who joked that his church's website was a test of faith because it took so long to load. But your church's website shouldn't be a patience-testing exercise—it should be a joy to visit. With a few tweaks and optimizations, you can have a site that loads faster than you can say, "Amen!"

Sign #5: Lack of Online Giving Options

Remember the old days when everyone would pass around a basket during service for donations? Well, things are a bit different now. More and more people are choosing to give online. It's fast, it's easy, and you don't have to remember to bring your checkbook or cash.

If your website doesn't have an option for online giving, it might be time for an upgrade. Think of it like this: if someone wants to give to your church but can't figure out how, it's like they're trying to open a door that's locked. It's frustrating and, eventually, they might just give up and walk away.

A while back, I worked with a church that only accepted donations during their Sunday service. They didn't have an online giving option, and it was hurting their donations. Once we added an easy-to-use online giving tool to their website, their donations increased. It was like opening a door that had been closed.

Sign #6: Your Website Doesn’t Reflect Current Events or Activities

Does your church have a calendar full of fun events, group meetings, and activities? Great! But if that calendar isn't updated on your website, how will anyone know about it?

Your website should be like your church's bulletin board, always showing the latest and greatest. If it's not up-to-date, people might think your church isn't active or that there's not much going on.

Here's a fun story: I once visited a church's website that had a "Christmas Service" banner prominently displayed... in July! Not only was it confusing, but it made me wonder if the church was still active. So, remember to keep your website updated with all the exciting things happening in your church.

Sign #7: No Social Media Integration

Imagine you're throwing a big party (remember those?). You're sending out invites via mail, phone calls, emails, and even through your friendly neighborhood pigeon. But you forget to post about it on social media. Suddenly, you're missing out on inviting a whole group of people who might have loved to come!

In the same way, if your church website isn't connected to your social media, you're missing out on a big chance to connect with people. Today, social media is a huge part of our lives. It's how we share updates, connect with friends, and find out about events.

If your church has social media accounts (and it should!), make sure they're linked on your website. And if you're sharing cool stuff on your social media, why not show it off on your website too? That way, even if someone stumbles upon your website first, they can easily join your online community.

One of the churches I worked with had a vibrant Instagram account, full of uplifting quotes, fun event photos, and community highlights. But you wouldn't know it from their website, which didn't have any link or mention of their social media. Once we added their Instagram feed to their homepage and linked all their social accounts, they saw an increase in online engagement. It was a simple change, but it made a big difference.

Your Next Steps to a Revitalized Church Website

So, is your church website giving off more "outdated attic" vibes than "welcome home" vibes? Don't fret—it's not the end of the world, and you're not alone. We're here to help.

We invite you to meet with our team for a no-strings-attached discovery session. It's a great chance to chat about your website's needs, share your vision, and see how we can help bring it all to life.

Ready to get started? Just click here to schedule your session: Let's make your church's website a place that truly feels like home. We can't wait to meet you!

Or Text Us At