Is Your Church Making These Common SEO Mistakes?

Mar 17, 2023

Have you ever wondered why your church website doesn’t pop up on the first page of Google? Or why your online attendance isn't growing as you'd hoped? If you've been grappling with these questions, then you've stumbled upon the right article. It might be that your church is making some common SEO mistakes, but don't worry—we’re here to help you navigate through this digital maze.

Now, we know SEO may sound like techie jargon, but trust us, it's as crucial to your church’s online presence as Sunday sermons are to your congregation. SEO, or Search Engine Optimization, is the secret sauce that helps your website appear in search engine results when people type in words related to your church. Think of it as the digital equivalent of a highway billboard directing people to your church—only it's much more efficient and less costly in the long run!

We at our agency have had the privilege of working with numerous churches, helping them amplify their digital presence and connect with more souls in their communities. We’ve seen the transformative power of SEO firsthand. One of our favorite success stories is a small community church in Kansas. When we first started working with them, their website was on the 5th page of Google. After optimizing their SEO, they're now consistently on the first page and have seen a 200% increase in online visitors. More visitors mean more opportunities to share God’s love and the church's mission.

But enough about us, let's dive into the nitty-gritty of SEO for churches and see if we can't get your church shining brightly on that digital highway!

Understanding SEO for Churches

Before we get into the common mistakes, let's first establish a basic understanding of SEO. Search Engine Optimization is all about improving your website so that it ranks higher in search engine results. When someone types "churches near me" or "Sunday service online," you want your church to be at the top of that list. This is where SEO comes in. It's a combination of technical factors, like website structure and speed, and creative elements, like content quality and keyword usage.

Why does SEO matter for churches, you ask? Well, we live in a digital age where most people turn to Google for answers. It's no longer just about word-of-mouth or the Yellow Pages. Your church's digital presence can make a significant impact on how you connect with your community and beyond. It's a powerful tool to reach people who might be looking for spiritual guidance, searching for a new church home, or even those who are just curious about faith.

Imagine a family that's just moved to your city. They're searching for a church to attend and they type in "church in [your city]." Will your church appear in the search results? If not, you could be missing out on welcoming new members to your congregation. And that's just one example!

Let me share a story from our experience. We worked with a church that had an amazing youth program, but you wouldn't know it from looking at their website or online presence. After we helped them optimize their website for keywords like "youth church programs" and "youth ministry in [their city]," they saw a significant increase in inquiries and attendance for their youth program. This is the power of SEO!

In the next section, we'll dive into some common SEO mistakes that churches often make. But don't worry, we'll follow that up with some easy fixes to help you start improving your church's SEO right away. Let's get started!

Common SEO Mistakes Churches Make

The road to a strong online presence can be a bit bumpy, and it's easy to make a wrong turn here and there. Here are some of the most common SEO mistakes we've seen churches make.

1. Lack of Keyword Research

First up, we have keyword research. In SEO, keywords are the terms and phrases that people enter into search engines. Knowing the right keywords to use is like having a roadmap for your SEO journey—it guides everything from the content you create to the meta descriptions you write.

Unfortunately, many churches overlook this crucial step. They either use very generic keywords, like "church" or "Christianity," which are highly competitive and difficult to rank for, or they use jargon that their target audience may not be familiar with.

One church we worked with was using the term "liturgical service" on their website. While this term was accurate, it wasn't a common search term among their local community. When we switched their language to more commonly searched terms like "traditional church service," their online visibility improved noticeably.

2. Poor Website Structure

Your website's structure is like the architecture of a building—it needs to make sense and be user-friendly. If it's difficult for people to navigate your website or find the information they need, they'll likely leave and go elsewhere. And search engines take note of this. If your website has a high bounce rate (the percentage of visitors who leave your site after viewing only one page), it can negatively impact your SEO.

A common mistake we see is churches burying important information deep within their website. For example, one church had their service times on a subpage of a subpage! It was like a digital scavenger hunt. We helped them streamline their website structure, making crucial information easily accessible, which improved both user experience and their search engine ranking.

3. Inadequate Content

Good content is the heart of SEO. It's what draws people in and keeps them coming back for more. But creating engaging, relevant content isn't always easy. Many churches struggle with this, often posting infrequently or publishing content that doesn't provide value to their audience.

We once worked with a church that only posted their weekly bulletins on their website. While this was helpful for their congregation, it didn't offer much to people outside their church looking for spiritual content or information about the faith community. After we worked with them to create a blog with a variety of content, they saw an increase in website traffic and engagement.

4. Neglecting Mobile Optimization

In our on-the-go world, people are more likely to browse the internet on their phone than on a computer. If your website isn't mobile-friendly, it can frustrate visitors and lead them to leave. Plus, search engines, Google in particular, prioritize mobile-friendly websites in their rankings.

A church we worked with had a website that looked beautiful on a desktop but was nearly impossible to navigate on a phone. Images were misaligned, text was too small to read, and the donation button (a crucial feature!) was missing entirely. By redesigning the website with mobile optimization in mind, we helped them improve their online visitor experience and their SEO.

5. Not Utilizing Local SEO

Lastly, many churches overlook the power of local SEO. This is the process of optimizing your online presence to attract more business from relevant local searches. For churches, this could mean appearing in searches for "churches in [your city]" or "[your denomination] church near me."

We once assisted a church that was located in a bustling downtown area but wasn't showing up in local search results. They were missing out on reaching commuters and people working in the area who might be interested in their services or community events. After optimizing their local SEO, including getting them set up on Google My Business and encouraging members to leave reviews, they saw a significant uptick in visits from locals.

So there you have it, friends—these are some of the most common SEO mistakes that churches make. But don't worry, we won't leave you hanging! In the next section, we'll share some practical tips to help you avoid these mistakes and improve your church's SEO. After all, we're on this journey together!

How to Avoid these SEO Mistakes

Now that we've identified the bumps in the road, let's map out how to navigate around them. Here are our top tips for each of the common mistakes we've discussed.

1. Conducting Effective Keyword Research

Let's start with keyword research. There are many free tools out there, like Google Keyword Planner and Ubersuggest, that can help you find the keywords your target audience is using. Try to find a balance between relevance, search volume, and competition. And remember to think like your audience—what terms would they use to find a church like yours?

For example, when we worked with a bilingual church, we discovered that a significant portion of their local community was searching for services in Spanish. By incorporating keywords like "Spanish-speaking church" and "bilingual services," they were able to connect with a whole new audience.

2. Improving Website Structure

When it comes to website structure, simplicity is key. Make sure crucial information—like service times, location, and contact information—is easy to find. A clear, intuitive navigation menu can also enhance user experience and keep people on your site longer.

Remember the church that hid their service times on a subpage? Once we brought that information to the homepage and simplified their navigation menu, their bounce rate decreased significantly, and their online engagement increased.

3. Creating Quality Content

Content is king in SEO. Aim to create content that provides value to your audience—this could be anything from blog posts on spiritual topics to recordings of your sermons. Try to post consistently, and remember to incorporate your keywords naturally within your content.

The church that only posted bulletins saw a tremendous increase in website traffic once they started a blog. They even had congregation members stepping up to write posts, which added a lovely personal touch to their content.

4. Ensuring Mobile Optimization

A mobile-friendly website is no longer optional—it's a must. Most website platforms offer mobile-responsive themes, so start there. Check how your website looks on different devices and make adjustments as needed. This could involve resizing images, adjusting text size, or rearranging elements for a smaller screen.

After we helped the church with their mobile-unfriendly website, they received feedback from congregation members who were thrilled to be able to easily access the website from their phones. It's amazing how small changes can make a big difference.

5. Harnessing the Power of Local SEO

Don't forget about local SEO! Make sure your church's name, address, and phone number are consistent across all online platforms. Claim your free Google My Business listing, and encourage your congregation to leave reviews. This can significantly improve your visibility in local search results.

The downtown church we mentioned earlier? They're now a prominent result when people search for "churches in downtown [their city]." They've even hosted several community events that attracted locals who discovered them through a Google search.

Remember, friends, SEO is a journey, not a destination. It takes time and continuous effort to see results, but it's worth it. So don't be discouraged if you don't see changes overnight. Keep refining your strategy, and trust that your efforts will bear fruit. In our next section, we'll wrap everything up and look at next steps for your church's SEO journey.


Whew! We've covered quite a bit of ground today, haven't we? Let's take a moment to recap:

We've discovered that SEO is an essential tool in expanding your church's digital footprint. It's not just for businesses—it's for anyone who wants to be found online, including your church.

We've identified common SEO mistakes that many churches make, from neglecting keyword research to overlooking the importance of mobile optimization. And we've explored how these mistakes can impact your online presence.

But most importantly, we've outlined practical tips to help you avoid these mistakes and improve your church's SEO. Conduct effective keyword research, improve your website structure, create quality content, ensure mobile optimization, and harness the power of local SEO.

It's okay if this all feels a bit overwhelming. Just like the journey of faith, the journey of SEO is one step at a time. You don't have to do everything at once. Choose one area to focus on first, and once you've made progress there, move on to the next.

And remember, you're not alone in this journey. We're here to help. If you have questions or need more guidance, don't hesitate to reach out. Our team at [Your Agency Name] would be thrilled to assist your church in enhancing its digital presence.

In this digital age, the internet is an incredible tool for spreading the Good News and connecting with the community. By improving your church's SEO, you can ensure your church is easily found by those seeking spiritual guidance, community connection, or a church home.

So, dear friends in faith and leadership, let's embrace this digital mission field together. Let's make sure your church is a beacon, shining brightly on the digital highway, guiding people home. Let's start this SEO journey together, one step at a time.

Schedule a free discovery call with our team

God bless you, and here's to your church's digital success!

Or Text Us At